The root cause of the american civil war is perhaps the most controversial topic in american history even before the war was over, scholars in the north and south began to analyze and interpret the reasons behind the bloodshed. But like most of the other monuments to the confederacy's lost cause, the statue in charlottesville was not built in the immediate aftermath of that war. One of the most sensitive and controversial issues that any civil war site interpreter will confront is the role of slavery in the south's decision to secede from and take up arms against the united states. Why the civil war was really about slavery and the original documents of the confederacy show quite clearly that the war was based on one by that point, the war was lost and few, if any. Article: why the confederacy lost the civil war: a review of gabor s boritt's book - this is a straight-forward review of gabor s boritt's book: why the confederacy lost the war.
Lost cause the term lost cause emerged at the end of the civil war when edward pollard, editor of the richmond examiner, popularized it with his book the lost cause, which chronicled the confederacy's demise. Explanations for confederate defeat in the civil war can be broken into two categories: some historians argue that the confederacy collapsed largely because of social divisions within southern society, while others emphasize the union's military defeat of confederate armies. The confederacy was dependent on overseas trade to earn money to fight the u s civil war once they were effectively blockaded, see reason above, they quickly ran out of money to purchase ammunition and supplies. Secession from the existing union led to the american civil war, a bloody, four-year struggle that left much of the south in ashes and ended its hope of creating a new confederacy of states on the north american continent.
For instance, drew gilpin faust has argued that the confederacy lost because southern women turned against the war this is true, but it begs a more important question: why did they turn against it the reason is that the military tide was turning against the confederacy. Although the reasons for the defeat of the confederacy in the american civil war are debated just as energetically as the causes of the war, the answer to the question, why did the south lose the war was actually answered a long time ago. All of the following were confederate strengths going into the civil war except a larger population and army toward the end of the war, many poorer whites in the south felt. The lost cause of the confederacy, or simply the lost cause, is an ideological movement that describes the confederate cause as a heroic one against great odds despite its defeat the ideology endorses the supposed virtues of the antebellum south , viewing the american civil war as an honorable struggle for the southern way of life  while. As this video clip explains, the reason why common statues to those who fought in the civil war look so similar is more than coincidence the surprising reason why so many civil war memorials look.
If correct, the civil war claimed more lives than all other american wars combined, and the increase in population since 1860 means that a comparable war today would cost 75 million lives. A new birth of freedom: the civil war, 1861-1865 narrates the history of the american civil war while the course examines individual engagements and the overall nature of the military conflict, the focus is less on the battlefield than on political, social, and economic change in the union and the confederacy. The south lost the civil war because of a number of factors first, it was inherently weaker in the various essentials to win a military victory than the north the north had a population of more than twenty-two million people to the south's nine-and-a-half million, of whom three-and-a-half million were slaves. The civil war officially ended on may 13, 1865, and the confederate states of america ceased to exist sources look away: a history of the confederate states of america.
The confederacy lost the civil war for a variety of reasons, chief among them a lack of resources and manpower the north had more soldiers, more manufacturing and agricultural capacity, and the ability to blockade southern ports. The civil war and reconstruction (hist 119) this lecture probes the reasons for confederate defeat and union victory professor blight begins with an elucidation of the loss of will thesis, which.
Historians debating the origins of the american civil war focus on the reasons why seven southern states declared their secession from the united states (), why they united to form the confederate states of america (simply known as the confederacy), and why the north refused to let them go. The confederacy, according to the author, the south enjoyed better military leadership than did the north in the first year or two of the war true in the introduction the editor suggests that the south did not lose the civil war, the confederacy did, because over 100,000 southerners from four southern states fought for the union. The american civil war was a good example of a revolutionary war - but one in which the side seeking to seize political power - the southern confederacy - failed to use revolutionary methods to its full advantage.
According to lee, the confederacy lost the american civil war not because it fought badly but because the enemy had more men and guns - indeed more everything. Based upon the study of original documents of thewar between the states (civil war) era and facts and information published by confederate veterans, confederate chaplains, southern writers and southern historians before, during, and after the war, i present the facts, opinions, and conclusions stated in the following article. Even after the war, as the lost cause rose, many veterans remained clear about why they had rallied to the confederate flag i've never heard of any other cause than slavery, wrote.
The south lost the civil war because they underestimated the political will of their fellow countrymen yes the north had more men and more stuff, but the south did not need to defeat the north only hold out and inflict damage until the north quit. The confederacy lost for both internal and external reasons the enormous superiority of the union in terms of manpower, money, and industrial strength was a necessary prerequisite for the defeat of the confederacy, but it did not foreordain a confederate defeat.